Review: The Changing World of Atheism

Cover image of "The Changing World of Atheism" by Paul Chamberlain

The Changing World of Atheism

The Changing World of Atheism, Paul Chamberlain. Cascade Books (ISBN: 9798385218837) 2026.

Summary: Discusses the shift in the definition of atheism, the burden of proof, and critiques of theism’s violence.

In my last years as a campus minister, I noticed a shift in how atheists argued. Previously, they would affirm “I believe God does not exist.” If they were open to discuss their belief, I’d invite them to offer reasons for their belief and how they’d come to this. And if they wanted to hear it, I offered the same.

But in recent years, I noticed atheists making a different kind of statement. They would say, “I do not believe God exists.” They would often liken that to saying that it was a similar statement to “I do not believe the tooth fairy exists.” It was interesting that they never said “I do not believe gravity exists”! Furthermore, by saying this they shifted the burden of proving that God existed to me as the Christian. Essentially, they were saying that they didn’t need to prove what they didn’t believe but those of us who do believe should give reasons for that belief.

Responding to this shift in definition of atheism and of the burden of proof is a significant part of this new book by Paul Chamberlain. Chamberlain uses a fictional three-way conversation between a Christian, an atheist, and an agnostic to show how this shift works and to gesture toward a response. Chamberlain observes that it trivializes atheism. Also, two can play that game. The theist could say “I don’t believe there is no god.” In addition, this is open to the clarification: “Are they saying both that they don’t believe there is a god and don’t believe there is not a god?” If so they are really agnostic. If not, however, they really are saying they do believe there is no god, a positive statement open to question.

Chamberlain also deals with three other contentions posed to argue against theism. Firstly, are arguments that theism is morally defective. These all are variants on the contention that the existence of evil shows God either to be good but not powerful, or powerful, but not good. None of this shows God is non-existent and it doesn’t reckon with the implications for human free will if God made a world where it was impossible to choose evil.

Secondly, are contentions that theism is rationally defective. Logical positivists argue that statements like “God exists” are logically meaningless. The problem is that logical positivism’s test of meaning is also logically impossible. Likewise, some pose the question of whether an omnipotent God can create a stone so big God cannot lift it. The problem is this is nonsense, on the order of a square circle. The answer is no, there is no such thing as a stone God cannot lift. God can create any size stone AND lift it.

Thirdly, atheists argue that theism breeds violence, in some form, war against the unrighteous. While religious people have committed violence, so have irreligious people, and perhaps more of it. We have to look elsewhere than theistic belief for the roots of violence. Furthermore, with regard to Christianity, there are the non-violent teachings and example of Jesus.

Most of the book is focused on these challenges to theism. However, the second, and much shorter part focuses on signs pointing to God. This consists of two chapters. The first argues that speaking of proof is the wrong idea. We are hard put to prove anything. Rather, what we do is offer reasons, or signs, that point to the reasonableness of what we believe. Chamberlain proposes six signs pointing to God: (1) Human DNA, (2) Human minds, (3) The reliability of our cognitive faculties, (4) Our moral convictions, (5) Our finely tuned universe, and (6) The existence of that universe.

This is a wonderfully concise resource for those engaged in conversations with atheists. It identifies the key issues. In campus ministry, I found that many, not all, who professed atheism, came from religious homes. Many had been shut down when they asked reasonable questions. Others had witnessed moral hypocrisy. Often, I sensed in their anger that they wanted theism, even Christianity to be true, but hadn’t met Christians who lived and thoughtfully argued for what they believed. I wanted them to encounter that in our ministry. There are times when we must live something before speaking about it. But then come the times where we need to meet good questions with good reasons, or even good questions. This book is a great example of how we might engage positively and cogently.

_____________

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for review.

The Weekly Wrap: November 8-14

woman in white crew neck t shirt in a bookstore wrapping books
Photo by cottonbro studio on Pexels.com

The Weekly Wrap: November 8-14

Genre Bookstores

I don’t get it.

A bookstore devoted to romantasy opened in our community. I’ve imagined walking in and asking a bookseller, “do you have anything here that I’d actually enjoy reading?” More likely, I probably just won’t visit.

However, I will concede that romance fiction in all its variants, including the fusion of romance and fantasy that is romantasy is hot. More people are reading books in those genres than anything else.

And the folks running this store, based on their social media, are doing everything right to build a community of readers through a variety of events and promotions. These people seem to be the kind who love these books and love gathering others who love them. I wish them every success.

But I wondered with my Bob on Books Facebook page about the interest in such stores. Generally, most felt as I do that they like bookstores with lots more options than one genre. Most of us have our favorites. But notice that is plural. No genre-specific store covers the breadth of our interests.

I also wonder about the long term viability of such stores. They depend on a community of interested readers regularly purchasing those books. And I suspect most won’t last long on buyers shelves. I think of a mystery bookshop that we used to visit occasionally that lasted maybe a decade. I buy mysteries as e-books at a discount, for the most part. There are ways to do that to support local stores, but I haven’t figured it out.

That also begs the question of whether the current interest in “romantasy” is a passing fad or a long term trend. Will the same readers buy these books in five years? Or will new readers come along?

There are exceptions. The Mysterious Bookshop in New York City stands out in my mind. I’m sure there are others. While I always love to see new stores, I see how hard it is for any indie store to make it, let alone ones focused more narrowly. I guess it all depends on forming a community of readers who keep supporting the store.

Five Articles Worth Reading

I’ve argued that AI doesn’t belong in publishing. “AI Is Destroying the Trust Between Writers and Readers” provides further evidence of the slop and scams that have intruded into publishing already. I laughed when Rachel Kadish, the article author interacted with an AI scammer named “Rachel Kadish.” That is, I laughed to avoid crying.

David Lehman, the editor of The Oxford Book of American Poetry, writes about the role of an editor of anthologies, in “Notes on Making a Canonical Anthology: The Oxford Book of American Poetry.” He maintains that “All anthologies perform an evaluative function.”

Janet Malcolm’s 1990 book The Journalist and the Murderer begins with the statement: “Every journalist who is not too stupid or too full of himself to notice what is going on knows that what he does is morally indefensible.” “Janet Malcolm, Master of Unsparing Profiles, Was Nicer Than You’d Think” reviews Eve Sneider’s The Absent Woman, a new biography on this imposing journalist.

Ian Marcus Corbin’s To Arrive Where We Started: Belonging in the Modern World, explores the connection between the search for roots and finding a sense of belonging. In “Digging for Roots,” Alan Jacobs reviews the book. In the review, he observes: “It seems obvious, then, that we do not need belonging as such, a sense of being at home in the world as such; we need, rather, to belong in the right ways, in ways that help us and those around us to achieve true flourishing, not a corrupted perversion of it that depends for its coherence on exclusion.”

Finally, poet Malcolm Guite is in the midst of a re-telling of the Arthurian legends. “21st Century Inklings: Malcolm Guite’s Arthurian Cycle” reviews the first two installments of the cycle, Galahad and the Grail and The Coming of Arthur.

Quote of the Week

Novelist Robert Louis Stevenson was born on November 13, 1850. He observed:

“That man is a success who has lived well, laughed often and loved much.”

I like that measure of success.

Miscellaneous Musings

This has been a week of tech collapses. Market freezers in Europe hacked and food spoiled. Jensen Huang of Nvidia’s moral collapse, followed by the crash of its stock. Microsoft’s worldwide outage of Outlook and other applications (boy am I glad I’m retired!). And the ground stop of all flights in the U.S. At least when the tech apocalypse comes, there are still candles, matches, and print books.

One of the books I’ll be reviewing next week is Christ in the Abyss by Jean L. Neely. It is her account of living with bi-polar (1) disorder. It is extraordinary. Neely gives an honest and vulnerable account of her life, one in which she continues to struggle with times in the abyss. She doesn’t write about how God “fixed” her or the ways she beat depression. Rather, she speaks of learning that even in the abyss, God is there, of the value of a community that accepts her as a bi-polar person, and learning to be gentle with herself.

Lastly, I’ve enjoyed George MacDonald’s fantasy. I can see how he was an influence on Lewis. This week, I started Malcolm, a novel set on the coast of Scotland. I’m enjoying not only the story but the moral universe implicit beneath the story.

Next Week’s Reviews

Monday: Paul Chamberlain, The Changing World of Atheism

Tuesday: Kevin Nye, Hope For the Mission

Wednesday: John Smed, Journey in Prayer

Thursday: Jean L. Neely, Christ in the Abyss

Friday: Barry B. Luokkala, Exploring Science Through Science Fiction

So, that’s The Weekly Wrap for November 8-14.

Find past editions of The Weekly Wrap under The Weekly Wrap heading on this page

Review: Miss Wolcott’s Ghost

Cover image "Miss Wolcott's Ghost" by Louise Penny

Miss Wolcott’s Ghost

Miss Wolcott’s Ghost (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, 21), Louise Penny. Minotaur Books (ISBN: 9781250412607) 2026

Summary: A call during the night connects back to Clara Morrow and leads to a decomposed body surrounded by a mysterious plant.

“There’s a body in Lost Nation.”

The call came to Armand Gamache’s personal phone at 3:17 am. The voice seemed familiar…and terrified. No number showed up on the caller ID but a trace showed it had come from Clara Morrow.

Lost Nation. It truly was a lost place, although known to one man in a nearby village. It was not far from Three Pines. So, the old man guides them there. And in a cemetery they find a badly decomposed body. Around it, and through it, they find growing a plant they’ve never seen before. The country’s leading botanist, Dr. Lagace, identifies it as Miss Wolcott’s Ghost, a plant thought to be extinct.

It was one of the plants found by an eccentric amateur botanist, Daisy Wolcott, over a century ago. She frittered away a fortune on journeys to gather plants. The scientific establishment thought her a kook. In the end, she scattered seeds of the plant in neighbors gardens wherever she went in Europe. Ugly, and invasive, they eradicated it. Or so they thought until it turns up in a grave. In Canada.

The body. A man in an old tweed suit. An autopsy revealed the killer hit him over the head with a shovel. He’s laying by a tombstone with the date May 29, 1914. There is no name, just an etched drawing of the herb rosemary. He’d probably been murdered in March, several months earlier. He had no ID and was so badly decomposed as to not be readily identifiable.

The date. May 29, 1914 was the day of the sinking of the Empress of Ireland, an actual event in which more passengers died than on the Titanic. But what connection did the body have to that tragedy?

Clara Morrow. Her phone didn’t make the call. Someone cloned her SIM card. She’d had two visitors around the time of the death, a genealogist by the name of Brian Fillmore and a journalist by the name of Jeannette Bouchard. Investigators discovered evidence that Clara’s house was searched. As the investigation unfolds, it turns out the interest was in Clara’s deceased husband Peter’s ancestors.

Lost Nation again. While researching its history, they discover a 1967 recorded interview of a young archivist with area resident Flossy Fuller. It ends with the word’s “and then there was the murder.” The next day, the young archivist and Flossy die in a tragic auto accident.

The voice. So, Gamache thought the voice familiar. When Gamache and Beauvoir visit, Reunion, the genealogy company Brian Fillmore and his brother Charles started, they encounter Gaston Comeau. He is a pariah to them. A former Surete’ officer, he had acted with cowardice under fire, compromising his team and in the second instance, jeopardizing Gamache. They turn away. Then he identifies himself with the words of the mysterious call and claims he can help

These are the pieces Gamache and his team must make sense of to find the killer of the man on the grave. Reading the story felt like staring at the pieces of a large jigsaw puzzle, trying to figure out how they all go together. Meanwhile, Miss Wolcott’s Ghost grows in Gamache’s garden, transplanted by Dr. Lagace. What is this ugly plant and how does it connect to a murder a century after it went extinct?

However, as we gaze at the puzzle pieces, we do so in the wonderful setting of Three Pines. Ruth and Rosa are having at it with Jean-Guy. The Bistro keeps serving up yummy food and drinks as the team and the residents puzzle over the mystery. Myra, as always, brings perceptive insights. Louise Penny must have heeded the fans who wanted more Three Pines.

While all this goes on, Gamache and others mentally replay the events during which Comeau betrayed the team. We learn that Gamache had hand-picked Comeau. And scene by scene he recalls confrontations with violent sociopaths doing mass killings at fast food restaurants, while Comeau hides in one instance, and is taken hostage the second time after disobeying orders. Having proven untrustworthy twice, how can they trust him now?

Louise Penny has created an intricate puzzle for readers, one that kept me turning the pages as I turned the pieces to see how they fit. It’s a story over a century in the making, and in the end, all the pieces fit in ways both surprising and delightful.

Review: How Then Shall We Read?

Cover image of "How Then Shall We Read?" by Max Botner

How Then Shall We Read?

How Then Shall We Read, Max Botner. Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co. (ISBN: 9780802883841) 2026.

Summary: An introductory textbook combining New Testament introduction and biblical hermeneutics.

In How Then Shall We Read?, Max Botner has written a book that may be used as a college text or for adult education. He combines two separate fields, New Testament introduction and biblical hermeneutics in a single book that may be used over a semester. This is less a traditional introduction to the New Testament, than an approach that uses hermeneutical basics with application to the New Testament, getting at many of the issues that arise in a more traditional introduction.

After an introduction where he lays out this approach, he proceeds with seven chapters concerning what “matters” in New Testament interpretation.

Interpretation Matters. He argues off the bat that biblicism, as Christian Smith has outlined it, perverts sola Scriptura. Rather, the issue is to develop interpretive virtues reflecting our embodiment. We look behind, within, and in front of the text. Then we also seek to cultivate the interpretive virtues of clarity, critical reflection, and charity. We do this self-aware of our interpretive location. Then we engage the text as wholly other. We follow this by opening the text to listen to the rich conversation across the canon and across the church. Finally, we embody the text as it intersects with our world. The following chapters proceed from this process.

Theology Matters. Consideration is given to the text of scripture as we have it and the canon(s). What does this mean for reading this text as Holy Scripture and how does our theology of inspiration and authority inform that reading? While we read by faith, shaped by these beliefs, Botner argues that “we let the Bible be the Bible.” We should not ask it to behave in ways it never promises to.”

History Matters. This addresses historical criticism, particularly understanding the world behind Jesus, Paul, and the gospels. This includes the ideas, identities, and institutions that shaped the early Jesus movement. Botner includes discussions of the synoptic problem, the undisputed and disputed Pauline letters, and the Jewish and Roman worlds behind the text.

Literature Matters. The chapter focuses on genre analysis and the basic genres of different books and the genres to be found within books. Many interpretive differences arise in disagreements about the genre of the text.

Language Matters. Botner begins by exploring how words mean and avoiding linguistic fallacies. Rather, words are part of discourses and Botner shows the student how to do a discourse analysis of the text.

Canonical Conversations Matter. Here the student will explore how the different voices within scripture are part of one conversation, illuminating each other. Botner considers how New Testament writers interpreted scripture. He elaborates five guiding principles for reading canonically.

Catholic Conversations Matter. Finally, he suggests we ought to read with the whole church in three ways: with the dead, with the majority world (outside the West), and with minority scholars within our own culture.

Each chapter also begins with quotes drawn from a variety of figures throughout history, illustrating how we read with the whole church. The chapters conclude with both a prayer from scripture and from a person in church history. Discussion questions on chapter content follow. Finally, each chapter includes an exercise, ranging from a self-awareness essay at the beginning, through use of historical, genre, discourse, and canonical analysis, and several concluding essays.

I found the way Botner models clarity, critical reflection, and charity to be the most winsome aspect of the book. Apart from the initial discussion of biblicism, which I felt important in “ground-clearing,” the book was free from polemical discussion. As exemplified in the prayers, the focus of the book was indeed on discovering divine love through the study of the scriptures. The exercises give readers room to develop their own interpretive skills and voice while growing more aware of their own social location. While the focus is the New Testament, much of what readers learn about interpretation is applicable to the Old Testament. Finally, I so appreciate his concluding chapter on reading the Bible with the whole church, a dimension I’ve only discovered later in life.

_____________

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for review.

Review: Moving Pictures

Cover image of "Moving Pictures" by Terry Pratchett

Moving Pictures

Moving Pictures (Discworld, 10), Terry Pratchett. Harper Perennial (ISBN: 9780063393356) 2025, first published 1990.

Summary: Victor, a failed student wizard and “Ginger” are drawn to Holy Wood to star in motion pictures but unleash unholy powers.

An old man dies near Holy Wood, setting loose forces long buried. Within months, Holy Wood becomes the home of moving pictures. Alchemists from Ankh-Morpork have invented a process by which tiny demons in a box paint images onto film, shown as “clicks” in theaters with machines using phosphorescent creatures to project the film images.

And so begins a craze that sweeps Ankh-Morpork. And Victor Tugelbend, a student wizard who deliberately fails and Cut Me Own Throat Dibbler, a sausage sandwich vendor are drawn to Holy Wood along with lots of wannabe “stars including Theda “Ginger” Withel. Victor and Ginger become stars. Meanwhile, Dibbler exchanges sausage vending for running the show, making bigger and bigger films culminating with Blown Away (a satire on Gone With The Wind).

Something special has descended upon them all, even Gaspode, a mutt of a dog who starts talking. He becomes Victor and Ginger’s agent (as well as Leddy, the Wonder Dog). On screen, Victor and Ginger have a “chemistry” that crowds flock to see. Posters portray them in a passionate “clinch.” Victor is the dashing hero rescuing the girl.

But it is all unreal, and something more sinister is going on. Ginger sleep walks to Holy Wood Hill, opening a door that releases unholy beings into the world. Victor, along with Gaspode, are the only ones who realize something sinister is afoot. But can they stop it before the beings take over Ankh Morpork?

It all culminates in the premiere of Blown Away. A series of zany scenes follow including a monstrous “Ginger” that holds the baboon librarian in its clutches (a humorous reversal of King Kong) and wizards in wheelchairs and on broomsticks. But will Victor succeed in being the real life hero?

At one level, it is all great fun with lots of satire and tongue in cheek parody of Hollywood. At another level, it makes me wonder about the “unreality” that the industry looses on the world and the consequences. Whatever is the case, I hope Victor Tugelbend will be back, for the name if nothing else!

Review: Christ and Covenant in Global Politics

Cover image of "Christ and Covenant in Global Politics" by Robert J. Joustra

Christ and Covenant in Global Politics

Christ and Covenant in Global Politics, Robert J. Joustra. IVP Academic (ISBN: 9781514007860) 2026.

Summary: A vision for global politics grounded in justice as rightly ordered love and covenantal pluralism.

Robert Joustra undertakes what few have tried to do–articulate a Christian vision for international politics. To do so, Joustra draws upon Augustinian and Reformed thought which he distills into two major ideas. The first of these is justice as rightly ordered love–ordo amoris. The second of these is covenantal pluralism–relations reflecting shared love expressed in shared commitments. They are pluralistic because the agreed upon political goods are proximate and penultimate, not requiring ultimate bonds

The book is in three parts. The first explores the question of justice in international relations. After articulating a biblical groundwork for his two main ideas, he discusses how realism, liberal internationalism, communism, and social constructivism conflict with his biblical account.

The second part, then, explores systems of justice in international relations. The big insight is that unlike systems of states, and the appearance of some form of global order in things like the G20, in fact anarchy is the rule of international relations. In such a situation, Joustra argues for an international politics based not on law but covenantal relations between countries built on a measure of trust and shared values, even though different countries might ground those values differently. The outstanding example of this is the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

The third part explores justice in action in international relations. He explores responses to plague, pestilence, and global boundaries as examples of the “tragedy of the commons.” Rather than global governance, Joustra points to covenant-like agreements such as those addressing ozone, acid rain, and ocean acidification. These were proximate rather than ultimate solutions. He wrestles with the morality of markets and economic life. And he articulates a version of just war theory as best conforming to rightly ordered love when nations resort to armed conflict and conclude those conflicts.

Some may fault Joustra for the lack of specific solutions to the international challenges faced by any statesperson. Personally, I’m glad he does not articulate visions of a global order, which are either scary or impractical. Rather, for the Christian engaged in statecraft, he articulates a basic framework of loving justice and covenantal relations, often in more localized spheres, such as North America, or the EU. Proximate agreements rather than ultimate solutions move justice between countries forward in a fallen world. Rather than hubris and power contests, he articulates what it is to “do justice, love mercy, and walk humbly” on an international basis. This is a valuable introduction that I’d love to see worked out in practice. And it makes a case that this is noble work for Christians.

_____________

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for review.