Review: Christ in the Abyss

Cover image of "Christ in the Abyss" by Jean L. Neely

Christ in the Abyss

Christ in the Abyss, Jean L. Neely, Ph.D. NavPress (ISBN: 9798898020347) 2026.

Summary: A memoir of living with bipolar disorder, discovering Christ’s presence, not in healing but in the depths of depression.

Note: This is a review of a book discussing depression and suicidal ideation that may distress some readers. If you are struggling, you are encouraged to reach out to a trusted pastor, counselor, or mental health professional. For immediate support, you can contact the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (in the U.S.) by calling 988 or visiting 988lifeline.org. Trained counselors are available 24/7 to listen and help.

Jean L Neely has lived with bipolar 1 disorder for several decades, since her adolescent years. The Cleveland Clinic website describes bipolar 1 disorder in this way: “You have at least one manic episode. It lasts at least seven days. It may be severe enough that you need hospital care. You also have episodes of depression.” This book fleshes out that definition with Neely’s honest narrative of the initial manic episode that landed her in the hospital, and subsequent episodes of both mania and depression. These are some of the best descriptions of bipolar disorder I’ve encountered.

Fortunately, Neely’s family acted quickly to seek medical care, resulting in a diagnosis and supportive treatment. But she also describes being part of a Christian community that emphasized spiritual growth through spiritual practices, as well as a self-critical approach identifying one’s faults and sins. There were also those who held out the hope of healing if one had enough faith. Consequently, Neely sometimes weaned herself off of medication, throwing herself into community, spiritual disciplines, and exercise. Either it seemed like she had really broken through during manic episodes, or was failing in seasons of depression.

She describes wondering where God was in what she called “the abyss.” Wasn’t God supposed to heal her? And when this didn’t happen, then she longed for God to put her out of her misery (she writes that her aversion to pain deterred her from self-harm). Yet the only thing that helped to a degree was her medication. A breakthrough came when she discovered that the God of scripture was present to the psalmist even in the depths of the sea. Another writer reminded her that “Silence is God’s first language.” Rather than fighting to get out of the abyss, she learned to befriend the abyss. She writes:

“What if Christ is the chasm? What if the chasm is none other than the One we can fall safely into and lose ourselves in, the One who catches us no matter how cluelessly we stumble or how low we fall?” (p. 141).

Neely also describes the importance of Christian communities that hold space for her, neither trying to “fix” her nor pressuring her to seek healing. Instead, they are present, supporting her in times of depression, urging her to get medical help if they see signs of manic episodes, and just loving her.

She also came to another insight as a young mother. Neely recognized the bond she had with her ten month old and realized that at ten months she was separated from her parents to live for over a year with relatives in Korea. She learned she spent the first weeks searching for her parents. Then, when she moved back home, this compounded the trauma as she had to separate from relatives who had become parents to live with strangers. Though not consciously aware of these experiences, she learns that such trauma can contribute to bipolar disorder and may help explain the abyss in her life.

Neely describes a journey from being self-critical to self-affirming. Rather than look at others, she recognizes that her own persistence in academic work is a heroic journey. Believing in the gentleness of Christ in the abyss allows her to be gentle with herself. And, while the abyss is still there, and still difficult, she is able to live with more hope. She concludes with five suggestions that have sustained her: (1) Just be, (2) Put sanity first, (3) Cultivate chasmic community, (4) Embrace true self, and (5) Trust in abyssal mercy. These serve as a succinct summary of the journey she narrates in this book.

This is one of the best books I’ve read on mental illness. Neely is both unflinchingly honest and eloquent. While helping us understand her experience of the abyss, she focuses not on herself but her encounter with the One who meets her in the abyss. She offers hope, not for healing, but for mercy and community to sustain her in the journey. She offers no platitudes or nostrums or neatly tied up resolutions. Rather, she invites us to join her in trusting that the Christ of mercy is in the abyss. He will see us through.

_____________

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for review.

Review: The Book of Susan

The Book of Susan, Melanie K. Hutsell. Brewster, MA: Paraclete Press, 2022.

Summary: A woman who seems to have it all, a successful husband, beautiful son, and tenure-track position begins to struggle with apprehensions about another woman who has come into her circle, visions apparently from God, anger and the inability to focus. As life unravels, she is diagnosed with a bipolar disorder and begins a long journey of discovery.

Dr. Susan Huffman seems to have it all together. A successful and esteemed husband, Sam, who is a chancery court judge, a beautiful son and a tenure-track position at a local college. She’s risen from humble beginnings in Clemtown. She has a wonderful circle of friends who have delightful dinner parties.

And then Lorraine comes. She joins the music making and upstages Susan and everyone else with her banjo. She shows effusive attention to Ian, Susan’s son, even giving him a stuffed animal, which becomes his favorite Lammykin. Susan perceives her as a threat to their circle. She starts keeping a journal. She has visions and undergoes a kind of spiritual awakening. But nothing dampens her suspicion of Lorraine who “just wants to be her friend.” There is a blow-up at a dinner party. Increasingly Susan seems to disconnect, sometimes unable to function, sometimes distracted. Then comes her blow-up with Ian as her husband walks in.

Susan knows something is not right and takes the first steps to get help. She sees a doctor who prescribes medication that doesn’t help. Then she sees a counselor, decides to take a leave from her faculty position, and finally sees a psychiatrist who diagnoses her as bipolar. Yet it seems too little, too late and she learns her husband is filing for divorce and custody of Ian. The rock bottom.

She returns to her home town and begins a journey of discovery. There is a kind of going back to move forward. The second half of the book describes not only how she came to terms with her illness through treatment, the kindness of the community, and even a fellow bipolar sufferer who connects her with a support group. Since spirituality was part of her descent into madness, she struggles with both wanting to believe and pray, and the knowledge that this was part of her descent.

Melanie T. Hutsell, the author, has lived inside this story as someone who has been diagnosed with a bipolar disorder for fifteen years. She helps us see how hard for someone with such a disorder to separate illness and reality (in fact, Susan had reason to be apprehensive of Lorraine). She traces the tortuous onset, the awakening to the fact that something is not right with oneself, and the long journey of therapy, care, and self-understanding that is part of the journey anyone with this condition must face. Through Susan, she helps us discover the power of “declaring membership in the fellowship of the flawed.”

In the end, I found myself wondering if the truly “deficient” one was Susan’s husband Sam, who could not tolerate the less-than-perfect marriage, and the uncertainty of the long road to healing for Susan. Perhaps Sam, having seen so much in chancery court, could not face the risk of a condition that wouldn’t get better. Melanie Hutsell does not back away from the reality that not all marriages survive the mental illness of a spouse. What she does is offer a sensitive, probing story of one who faced a bipolar disorder, a story with both loss and the hope, that even with a difficult condition, one may grow and find one’s place.

________________________________

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary review copy of this book from the publisher.