Review: The Changing World of Atheism

Cover image of "The Changing World of Atheism" by Paul Chamberlain

The Changing World of Atheism

The Changing World of Atheism, Paul Chamberlain. Cascade Books (ISBN: 9798385218837) 2026.

Summary: Discusses the shift in the definition of atheism, the burden of proof, and critiques of theism’s violence.

In my last years as a campus minister, I noticed a shift in how atheists argued. Previously, they would affirm “I believe God does not exist.” If they were open to discuss their belief, I’d invite them to offer reasons for their belief and how they’d come to this. And if they wanted to hear it, I offered the same.

But in recent years, I noticed atheists making a different kind of statement. They would say, “I do not believe God exists.” They would often liken that to saying that it was a similar statement to “I do not believe the tooth fairy exists.” It was interesting that they never said “I do not believe gravity exists”! Furthermore, by saying this they shifted the burden of proving that God existed to me as the Christian. Essentially, they were saying that they didn’t need to prove what they didn’t believe but those of us who do believe should give reasons for that belief.

Responding to this shift in definition of atheism and of the burden of proof is a significant part of this new book by Paul Chamberlain. Chamberlain uses a fictional three-way conversation between a Christian, an atheist, and an agnostic to show how this shift works and to gesture toward a response. Chamberlain observes that it trivializes atheism. Also, two can play that game. The theist could say “I don’t believe there is no god.” In addition, this is open to the clarification: “Are they saying both that they don’t believe there is a god and don’t believe there is not a god?” If so they are really agnostic. If not, however, they really are saying they do believe there is no god, a positive statement open to question.

Chamberlain also deals with three other contentions posed to argue against theism. Firstly, are arguments that theism is morally defective. These all are variants on the contention that the existence of evil shows God either to be good but not powerful, or powerful, but not good. None of this shows God is non-existent and it doesn’t reckon with the implications for human free will if God made a world where it was impossible to choose evil.

Secondly, are contentions that theism is rationally defective. Logical positivists argue that statements like “God exists” are logically meaningless. The problem is that logical positivism’s test of meaning is also logically impossible. Likewise, some pose the question of whether an omnipotent God can create a stone so big God cannot lift it. The problem is this is nonsense, on the order of a square circle. The answer is no, there is no such thing as a stone God cannot lift. God can create any size stone AND lift it.

Thirdly, atheists argue that theism breeds violence, in some form, war against the unrighteous. While religious people have committed violence, so have irreligious people, and perhaps more of it. We have to look elsewhere than theistic belief for the roots of violence. Furthermore, with regard to Christianity, there are the non-violent teachings and example of Jesus.

Most of the book is focused on these challenges to theism. However, the second, and much shorter part focuses on signs pointing to God. This consists of two chapters. The first argues that speaking of proof is the wrong idea. We are hard put to prove anything. Rather, what we do is offer reasons, or signs, that point to the reasonableness of what we believe. Chamberlain proposes six signs pointing to God: (1) Human DNA, (2) Human minds, (3) The reliability of our cognitive faculties, (4) Our moral convictions, (5) Our finely tuned universe, and (6) The existence of that universe.

This is a wonderfully concise resource for those engaged in conversations with atheists. It identifies the key issues. In campus ministry, I found that many, not all, who professed atheism, came from religious homes. Many had been shut down when they asked reasonable questions. Others had witnessed moral hypocrisy. Often, I sensed in their anger that they wanted theism, even Christianity to be true, but hadn’t met Christians who lived and thoughtfully argued for what they believed. I wanted them to encounter that in our ministry. There are times when we must live something before speaking about it. But then come the times where we need to meet good questions with good reasons, or even good questions. This book is a great example of how we might engage positively and cogently.

_____________

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for review.