Yesterday I made the contention that the scandal of the Church in America is that it is deeply divided within itself, that we have deeply rent the body of Christ, and that these divisions reflect the divisions in our country rather than the unity of people across our differences in Christ.
So what can and must be done?
I am not proposing that we all just try to gather in some kind of circle around a campfire, hold hands, and sing “Kumbaya.”
First of all, I believe we must awaken. I wonder whether most of us are all that disturbed that the Church in America is divided within itself and that we often include fellow believers in “the enemies” we are fighting and attacking (even when we’ve been told that our warfare is not to be against flesh and blood). I wonder if we are caught up so much with the urgency and the grievances of our particular tribe of Christians, and those with whom we have made common cause that we are woozy like boxers who have been punching each other too long.
Second, I believe we need to lament our sad state. We may not have a clue how we can mend the wounds between us. That tells us how desperate things are. It acknowledges that we need an intervention from on high. Lamenting takes us into a place where we realize our desperate need for God, and that to go on in the way we have is increasingly intolerable.
Third, as we begin to grasp our own contribution to the deep divisions that exist among believers, and the ways we have wronged in word, thought, and deed, in personal acts and unjust structures, we need to repent. Repenting is to call our own sins for what they are, to acknowledge them to God, and the wronged person as wrong, to come to terms with the real hurt and harm we have caused, and to acknowledge our intent, with God’s help to live differently and to determine what that difference will look like. Often we need to do this with the offended.
Repenting is hard, particularly when we think the other might have more to repent of than do we. Often the others think it the other way around. The question sometimes is simply, who will end the rounds of accusations and begin the process of repentance and restoration?
Fourth, we can begin to engage with our fellow believers across our differences and often at this point, what is most needed is simply to attend. To attend is to listen to understand rather than to refute. Can we listen well enough that we can repeat what is said in a way that the other recognizes that we understood them? We may have to ask ourselves beforehand whether we are truly open to such dangerous listening, because it may open us to different ways of seeing things.
Fifth is that I believe there is a necessity at times to contend. We cannot start here, I think, because I think so many of the things we would contend for are things in which we are deeply invested. The process of awakening, lamenting, repenting, and listening, may help us discern where we are healthily and unhealthily invested, enabling us to advocate for the right reasons, as well as with the right demeanor. But there are things where we really do disagree. The question is whether we will ever seek to come to a meeting of the minds, or at least to identify what we can agree upon and work from that. So often, differing parties only contend in their books and talks directed toward those who agree with them.
Sixth, this may lead us to amend our ways toward each other and toward how we address each others concerns.
I dream of several changes that might flow out of this:
- I hope this would lead our churches into a similar process of listening deeply to God, the Holy Scriptures, and one another, more intensely than to the political echo chambers that form many of our views.
- I would hope public Christian leaders would sit down with those who differ greatly to practice these steps and model them for others. Imagine if Franklin Graham, from Samaritan’s Purse, and Jim Wallis from Sojourners met each other as believers and modeled this effort toward coming to a common mind and communion of heart.
- I dream of the day when Christians, instead of aligning with one political party or another, would line up together to advocate for public policies that reflect the whole of the counsels of the Bible and challenge both parties to end the either-or approaches that characterize so much of our politics that set our people against each other.
As I wrote yesterday, I am convinced that if we do not work at composing and reconciling our differences in the American Church, we have little right or hope of expecting our American politicians to do it. I believe this is urgent for several reasons:
- Christ is grieved and not glorified by how we have torn asunder his Body.
- Our divisions sow seeds of doubt about the power of our gospel.
- Our children are abandoning many of our churches because of our behavior around these divisions.
- If we allow our divisions across race, gender, economics, and politics to continue, we will only aid and abet the inflaming of differences that could lead to a very scary future, and not one from powers outside our country.
Where am I beginning? I’ve decided that from now through Lent I am not going to post political posts or comments in social media in order to work on the six steps above in my own life. I’ve become increasingly aware of my own participation in the divisions about which I’ve written. I’m also going to look for at least a few fellow believers with views different from mine who would be open to practice this with me (anyone interested?).
Do me a favor, would you? If you think these posts on target, pass them along to church leaders you know, locally or nationally. I don’t want to see our generation repeat the error of church leaders in the pre-Civil War era. I hope instead they will say, “we must reconcile our differences and lead our country in doing the same.”
3 thoughts on “The Scandal of the Church in America: Part Two”
Wow. I have been increasingly concerned over this issue in recent months. I’m Canadian, and while the division is perhaps less obvious here, it exists nonetheless. Most of it is currently revealed by people’s comments about what has been happening in the US (How oddly Canadian!). For me, it is complicated by my own recent reassessment of my view of God and what it looks like to follow Him; I’m struggling to identify with either the progressives or the conservatives. The downside of this is that I feel disconnected from the majority of believers; like I don’t fit anywhere. I guess the upside is that I find myself in a position in the middle that allows me to listen to both sides, which I think is much needed right now.
What I appreciate most about your post is that you offer some biblically sound, concrete steps to take in pursuit of a solution. Thank you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Robin, thank you. I’m sure you Canadians must routinely scratch your heads at us crazy Americans. Hope you will pray for us as well. I don’t know the specifics of your journey but probably entertain similar thoughts. The communion of the saints is an important idea for me, including those in other nations, and those who have gone before us.
Pingback: Your Favorite “General” Posts of 2017 | Bob on Books