Growing Up in Working Class Youngstown — South High School

South High School, circa 1916

It was a time when Youngstown was undergoing explosive growth and particularly expanding south of downtown. Between 1900 and 1920 the population grew from 44,885 to 132,358. In 1910, there was one high school serving the city, The Rayen School. School superintendent N. H. Chaney started leading a campaign to expand the Youngstown City school system.

Architect Charles F. Owsley, the architect for the Mahoning County Courthouse, was employed to design the building. Looking at both buildings, you can see the family resemblance. Metro Monthly has a video online of both exterior details and pictures of the interior of the school. It was a grand building–the auditorium, ceilings, the school offices. The cornerstone was laid in 1909 and the school opened in 1911. The Rayen School had a reputation for excellence, and the opening encountered skepticism that the new school would match Youngstown’s first school for excellence. Superintendent Chaney assured parents of students that would be sent to South High School that they would be prepared just as effectively for life.

Whether the school matched The Rayen School in academics, South quickly proved itself in athletics, defeating Rayen in their first football match 12-0. For many years to come, this would be the major rivalry between Youngstown schools. By 1914 money had been appropriated for a new stadium behind the school. One of the early football stars at South High School under “Busty” Ashbaugh was Chet McPhee, who played at half back, graduating in 1915. After college, he returned to Youngstown to coach at newly established Chaney High School, a new rival for South.

During the flu epidemic of 1918, South High School was converted to an emergency hospital for a time, when existing hospital capacity was overwhelmed. Approximately 380 patients were cared for there, 90 of whom died, including three teachers who had volunteered their services.

Perhaps the most illustrious alumnus of South High School was Edward J. DeBartolo, Sr. in 1927. Judge Nathaniel R. Jones was another South High School grad, who eventually rose to the second highest court in the land. Football players Bob Dove and Fred Mundee as well as Major Generals Wilbur Simlik and Robert Durkin were graduates. In later years, Simeon Booker who wrote on civil rights in Jet Magazine was also a graduate. Joseph Napier, Sr, is another South High grad and Youngstown storyteller. One of his videos recounts “The Youngstown South Nine,” South’s one championship cross country team in 1980. Napier was a member.

Warrior Logo

At Chaney, we went to a lot of games at South’s stadium, one of two serving the high schools in the city. The South High Warriors in their red and blue were often a tough opponent in football and basketball. My other major encounter with South was the field house, from which I graduated. Beyond those experiences, I did not have a lot of contact with South and don’t think I was ever in the building. From the pictures I’ve seen, that was my loss.

Population was the reason South High School was built and it was the reason it closed. As Youngstown’s population shrank in the 1980’s and early 1990’s, Youngstown closed a number of schools. In 1993, the decision was made to close South High School. For a time, a charter school used the facility, Eagle Heights Academy. Eagle Heights Academy came under scrutiny because of poor academic performance and financial irregularities around 2010 and eventually closed. A new school, South Side Academy, took its place, and in 2015 moved out of the South High facility due to dissatisfaction with White Hat Management, who at that time owned the building. South Side moved into the former St. Patrick’s Elementary at 1400 Oakhill, out of which they currently operate.

It is not clear to me whether the South High School building has a tenant at present. The satellite map from this year suggests that the bleachers in the stadium are deteriorating, and I wonder from looking at it about the condition of the roof. If that goes, then the interior will deteriorate quickly. This would be sad–it is a gem of a building and a South Side landmark. And it represents an illustrious history as the city’s second high school, one that launched many students into life.

To read other posts in the Growing Up in Working Class Youngstown series, just click “On Youngstown.” Enjoy!

16 thoughts on “Growing Up in Working Class Youngstown — South High School

  1. South High epitomized the diversity and energy of working class Youngstown.
    As a 1967 graduate of South, I am especially grateful to its dedicated teachers, such as:
    Mr. Alfred Beach
    Mr. William Blascak
    Ms. Alice Carter
    Mr. Martin Cherry
    Mr. J. Frederick Klimko
    Ms. Emilyn Laskin
    Mr. John McAfee
    Mr. Alfred Sferra
    Thank you for your wonderful histories of our hometown and community..

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I had a geometry class with Busty Ashbaugh the year he died, 1953, my sophomore year at South High. Busty would sit at the head of the class behind his desk on the raised platform and begin talking geometry stuff. When we were to have a test, one of us would ask Busty a question, “Mr. Ashbaugh, is it true someone let a dog run across the football field during a game?” Busty would smile and start telling the story. We had heard this story before, but he didn’t seem to mind the retelling a bit. The next thing we knew the bell rang and the class was over. No test.

    It was apparent even to us fifteen-year-olds that Busty was ill. While talking his head would slowly drop down and his eyes would close and he napped off. A few minutes later, his head would slowly turn up to face us and he would pick up where he left off without missing a word. This happened at least once every class. We all got out early for his funeral.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks So Much
    Bob you have touched my heart with this article about my Alma mater South High School which closed in 1993 but it will always hold a very special place in my heart , In my Senior year 1981 Youngstown City Schools had a prolonged strike that almost prevented me from graduating on time they decided not to penalize the students also South High reverted back to having a freshman grade that year raising the student enrollment to well over 1,400 students .

    Thanks for mentioning about my Youngstown South Nine video short and providing a Link in this article as well .

    Joseph Napier Sr.
    Napiervision Productions

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Have you watched The Place the Makes Us? It’s about the enthusiastic young people hoping to remake the city and discusses a new use for South. The documentary is on PBS or WorldChannel. Its a real tearjerker but also inspirational. Here’s to their success.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Thank you for this fine article on my high school alma mater. I was the valedictorian of the class of 1965. So many memories. Mr. Cherry was the finest math teacher I ever had. I was sitting in his Plane Geometry class when the unforgettable announcement came over the PA system that President Kennedy had been shot.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: Growing Up in Working Class Youngstown — Your Favorites of 2021 | Bob on Books

  7. I am a graduate 1991 and I wish YCSD would take it back and make it a youth center for our youth so they can have some where to go to be safe and productive, our city has nothing left for our youth and it’s a shame to let the school sit. Renovations started prior to my graduation and continued so the building should be in great condition

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.