Review: Do Muslim and Christians Worship the Same God?

Do Muslims and Christians Worship the Same God?, Andy Bannister. London: Inter-Varsity Press (UK), 2021.

Summary: A comparative study of the worldviews of Christianity and Islam that concludes that the two do not worship the same God.

Years ago, a very thoughtful student, from a country where Christians were a minority in a largely Muslim country, asked me whether Muslims and Christians worship the same God. After all, Allah is the Arabic term for God and Islam traces its roots back to Abraham, one of the three Abrahamic faiths. And in fact, many commentators, promoting good will between the faiths, have proposed this idea. Miroslav Volf, for example, in Allah (Goodreads review) contends that he would say “yes, with different understandings of the God we worship.”

Andy Bannister first began wrestling with this question when he got involved speaking about his faith at the Speakers Corner in Hyde Park in London as he was engaged by a number of Muslim questioners. He eventually pursued a Ph.D in Qur’anic Studies. His careful analysis of the Qur’an and a comparison of the worldviews of Christianity and Islam led him to conclude “no.” He concluded that the differences were so great that the affirmative failed to do justice to either set of beliefs.

First of all, he deals with the obstacle of asserting that is arrogance to assert that one’s faith is true to the exclusion of others. He observes how we want to be reasonably certain of truth in many other areas of life, for example medical treatment, and we don’t consider it arrogant when a doctor prescribes a course of treatment. We want this. We don’t want a tolerant, inclusive doctor who says, “whatever.” The real issue is how we treat those with whom we disagree. Are we gracious and humble in stating our convictions or cocky? Arrogance is a behavior that need not be associated with a belief that something is true.

Bannister then outlines his approach, which is to consider the answers to four basic worldview questions:

Is there a god, and, if so, what is god like? He states that the God of the Bible is relational, knowable, holy, love, and has suffered. He contends that the Qur’an rejects, ignores, or overwrites each of these with a different portrayal of Allah.

Who and what are human beings? Whereas Christianity understands Christians as made in the image of God and made to enjoy relationship with God and to reflect God’s character to all creation, Islam would hold that while humans are elevated, one relates to Allah as servant to master rather than child to father.

What is wrong with the world? Christians believe that our nature is deeply affected by sin, which separates us from relationship with God and each other and the rest of creation. Islam sees us as made, not for relationship, but for obedience to Allah, but we are weak and fallible and often disobey his commands.

What is the solution? The idea of salvation is alien to Islam. Allah guides one in the right way and the obedient are rewarded with a pleasure-filled paradise, although one where Allah’s presence is not mentioned. Christians believe that our situation as alienated rebels is so desperate that self-help or even God-guided self-improvement is not adequate. We need saving or rescuing. God’s rescue plan is the sacrifice that dies in one’s places–sacrifices in the Old Testament that point to the sacrifice of Jesus, God’s once-for-all, perfect sacrifice, restoring us to a relationship with God.

He goes on to discuss Jesus, who is referenced in 90 verses in the Qur’an. He observes the unusual character of Jesus compared to other prophets that makes him something of a misfit in the Qur’an, but not in the Bible, where he is more than a prophet, revealing the character of God as God-with-us.

He concludes by describing Christianity as the most inclusive exclusive faith in the world–an open exclusivism where all who repent and believe are welcome, and only those who refuse are on the outside. He explores the nature of forgiveness–costly for the one who forgives but free to the forgiven, something that cannot be repaid, bought or earned. Bannister proposes that many of the longings for God which Muslims pursue may only be met in Christ–the longing for intimate love and compassion and forgiveness and relationship. His invitation is to come home.

Bannister combines extensive knowledge of the Qur’an, which is quoted in translation throughout with a clear analysis of fundamental differences that is not belligerent but matter of fact, and proven out in many personal interactions with Muslims. He also has a delightfully cheeky sense of humor, illustrated when he talks about playing Cluedo, known in the U.S. as Clue. He writes:

“For example, if you announce, “The killer was Miss Scarlet, using the dagger, in the conservatory’, and I disagree stating it was ‘Professor Putin, with a nerve agent, in the potting shed’, then we can immediately notice a few things. First, we cannot both be correct: our two theories disagree on every key detail and cannot both be right. Second, despite our fundamental differences, we are still both trying to answer the same basic questions; we agree about the questions–we just disagree about the answers. (And third, with theories like mine, I should probably avoid holidaying in Moscow.) (p. 35).

Throughout, we find this combination of careful, reasoned argument leavened with wit and warmth that makes this an enjoyable read. It is helpful as a resource if you’ve asked or been asked the title question, and particularly if this is in the context of friendships with those who embrace Islam. Bannister sees fundamental differences between Christianity and Islam but does so without demonizing Muslims but rather shows the utmost respect. Such an approach, I believe leads to dialogue that moves beyond the superficial to the substantive, allowing the exploration of each faith on its own terms, rather than those superimposed by the patronizing “let’s all just get along because we really are all on the same journey up the mountain.”

____________________________

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary review copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.

9 thoughts on “Review: Do Muslim and Christians Worship the Same God?

  1. I prefer to accept the statement given in the Catechism of the Catholic Church: “841 The Church’s relationship with the Muslims. “The plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator, in the first place amongst whom are the Muslims; these profess to hold the faith of Abraham, and together with us they adore the one, merciful God, mankind’s judge on the last day.”

    Liked by 1 person

      • Great review. It is either out of ignorance or insincerity for anyone to read the Quran, Hadith and also study the Bible and then claim that Allah and the God of the Bible.
        There is also another book “Who is this Allah?” By Moshay that also shows a great scholarly work in determining the Allah of Islam.

        Like

  2. In preparing for a public dialogue (debate) with a Muslim leader in Houston, I found Ayman S. Ibrahim’s “A Concise Guide to the Quran” very helpful. I believe Prof. Ibrahim was a speaker at the 2021 ETS (Evangelical Theological Society) national conference, which was focused on Islam. It seems to me if we take seriously the revelation of God in Scripture as being Trinitarian, then any unitarian depiction of God (such as Allah) that also departs from the Judeo-Christian line would have only slight overlap with the Trinity. Charitably, I’d like to think we’re worshiping the same God all around. But historic Christian orthodoxy is very specific about the doctrine of the Trinity, which cannot be reduced to anything else.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I’m puzzled. I well agree that the Name of the Christian God is “Father, Son and Holy Spirit” i.e., a Trinitarian name for God. However, the Name of the Judaic God is “YHWH,” which is the name of a monotheistic God lacking three Persons, i.e., a non-Trinitarian name. I have consistently believed that YHWH and Father-Son-HolySpirit are names for the same God. If so, why is it that “Allah,” the Name of a non-Trinitarian God of Muslims, cannot be used for the same Creator of all of the children of Abraham? Our human condition seems to require “names” for all material elements, as exemplified by Moses who requested the name of a burning bush. We all, also, have the need for theology, a word-filled human explanation of the “Theos” who created all of us. And yes, my own belief relies entirely on the “Father, Son and Holy Spirit” theology. I also believe there is a single Creator, the ipsum esse, who has diverse Names held by diverse people.

    Like

    • A few thoughts. YHWH is the vowels for how God disclosed God’s self to Moses that may be translated as “I am” It is significant that Moses didn’t make this up but God verbally disclosed this. Some of this had to do with what was God and what was not god. It is significant that in Genesis, God declares, “Let us make” The apostle Paul says that all things were created by God the Father through Christ (Colossians 1). While the Old Testament doesn’t explicitly reveal a Three-personed God, the idea that God is Love eternally (not just that God loves) can only true if God exists in relationship with God’s self. Jews, including Jesus himself who believed in one God were the very ones to formulate a Three-personed God to explain what they were discovering in Jesus and at Pentecost, the Holy Spirit–another counselor. Islam denies this.
      What Bannister also argues is that what Christians and Muslims understand about God vastly differ. We may, for example believe in birds. But bald eagles and penguins are very different creatures. A bald eagle is not a penguin. That is what Bannister argues. The two religions “God” or “Allah” both fall into the category of gods. But if they are vastly different, there is the question of whether either or neither is “the real thing.” What isn’t an option is that they both can be.
      As a Christian, I believe that God has helped us with that, not just by sending prophets, but by coming in human flesh to reveal himself and the way to Him. Again, Islam vigorously disagrees.

      Many just want to say, why don’t you all just ignore these differences and get along? Actually, suppressing difference creates greater hostility in my experience. Some of the best interfaith relationships I’ve had have allowed this honest disagreement coupled with mutual respect for the sincerity of individuals. It’s not finally our job to judge, and I’ve found that even with our differences, we all humbly trust ourselves to the judgement of God, or whatever ultimate reality we affirm. We can be diverse and disagree, My devout Muslim, Jewish, Sikh, Buddhist, and Hindu friends all disagree. But that needn’t preclude us from being friends.

      Like

  4. Pingback: The Month in Reviews: April 2022 | Bob on Books

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.