Literary fiction

Review: Martyr!

/ rtrube54 / Leave a comment
Cover image of "Martyr" by Kaveh Akbar

Martyr!, Kaveh Akbar. Vintage Books (ISBN: 9780593685778) 2024.

Summary: A young immigrant poet in recovery struggles to find meaning in a life after his mother’s plane was shot down and his father died.

When Cyrus was an infant in Iran, his mother’s plane was shot down by mistake by a U.S. ship. His father moved to Indiana, seeing a job recruitment notice. He spent the rest of his life cleaning up after chickens and collecting their eggs. And died when Cyrus was in college. Meanwhile his uncle Arash stayed back in Iran, suffering PTSD from the war. He had a gruesome assignment, to ride a black horse through battlefields at night after battle, robed as the Angel of Death. The idea was to comfort the dying. But he would live ever after with what he saw and did.

Cyrus was basically a good boy until his father died. In college, he experimented with all the things many students did, becoming addicted to drugs and alcohol. One day, he awoke and considered suicide, praying for a sign that he should go on living. A “sort of” sign was good enough to get him into recovery.

Cyrus was a poet and writer–or at least aspired to be. Talking with friends, he shared his idea to write a book about martyrs–people who died for something greater than themselves. And in this, we come to a central idea of the book–can one’s life–and death–mean something? He learns from a friend that an Iranian artist in New York named Orkideh is holding a unique exhibition. The exhibit is called Death-Speak. She is the exhibit, a woman dying of metastatic breast cancer willing to talk with any who come about death or whatever they want to talk about.

Cyrus and his lover, Zee, decide to make the trip. And for three consecutive days, he has conversations with Orkideh. At the beginning, she mocks his aspiration to write a book on martyrdom –“another death-obsessed Iranian man?” But by the end, there is a bond as he shares he wants to write about her. By the third conversation, they have become close. Orkideh seems gladdened to see Cyrus. He trusts her with his struggle and comes to his central question, “the trick to being at peace at the end.” They talk a bit further and embrace. He will never see her again. But those conversations and what he learns after them will change him forever…

While the book centers around Cyrus, each of the significant characters narrates at different points, sometimes filling in backstory. The narrative moves from the present back as far as Cyrus’ childhood. We hear from Cyrus father Ali, mother Roya, uncle Arash, Orkideh, and even Orkideh’s gallerist and former lover. There is even a strange, dreamlike segment with Orkideh and “President Invective.” There are also short segments with quote’s from Cyrus’ book on martyrs.

These shifts allow the reader to catch one’s breath, or redirect one’s eye in the story Akbar is painting. The story is one of discovery, one in which Cyrus gains knowledge of himself and the meaning of creating and loving. Akbar offers us an exploration of the human condition in all of its heartbreaks, ambiguities, and noble aspirations. Life can be both messy and glorious and our task is learning to live with both.

Review: We Do Not Part

/ rtrube54 / Leave a comment
Cover image of "We Do Not Part" by Han Kang

We Do Not Part, Han Kang, translated by E. Yaewon and Paige Aniyah Morris. Hogarth (ISBN: 9780593595459) 2025

Summary: Kyungha makes a harrowing journey through a blizzard to save a friend’s bird, confronting the reality behind her nightmares.

The nightmares began a few months after Kyungha, a historian, published a book on a massacre. She is making her way in a blizzard through a field of erect torsos like tree stumps as the sea behind her rises…. In the years since, she has struggled with depression and considered suicide. But she shared her dream with Inseon, a photographer who collaborated with her on documentaries. Inseon, who has become a friend, agrees to create an installation that will remember the massacre that was the source of the dreams. Kyungha is not so sure about this idea and asks her friend to drop the project.

Then she receives a text from Inseon, asking her to come to a hospital. Inseon, a woodworker, cut off the tips of a couple fingers and is undergoing a gruesome set of treatments that will last weeks to try to save the tips of her fingers. She has a favor to ask of Kyungha. In the rush to get her to hospital, she left behind her bird, that will soon die without food or water. Inseon lives on the island of Jeju in a remote location by a remote village. Getting there involves flights, bus rides, and hiking a trail up to her remote home. There is no one back home who she can ask to do this.

There are some things you do not deny a friend of twenty years. Kyungha departs immediately only to discover that she is flying into a blizzard. She is not adequately dressed. She manages to get the last bus to the village. Then, in a blinding storm, she has to make her way up to Inseon’s house. Kyungha gets lost, falls, yet miraculously makes her way. She is cold with soaked shoes. She soon begins to feel feverish.

This sets the stage for the second half of the novel, which reads like something of a fever dream. She finds Inseon had not abandoned their project, having cut one hundred logs for the installation. More than that, through a series of visions/dreams/hallucinations, Inseon recounts her mother’s personal accounts of the massive genocide that occurred on Jeju in 1948-1950. The South Korean government, with assistance from the United States, embarked on an effort to cleanse the island of Communism, resulting in the deaths of over 300,000 people [this really happened].

Kyungha confronts the nightmare reality of which her dreams were but a figment. It’s a personal account of Inseon’s mother, father, and extended family, many of whom died. But she experiences something else–the bond between her and Inseon of which the title speaks. Han Kang juxtaposes unspeakable violence and enduring friendship. She captures something of both the unspeakable evil of which we are capable and the nobility that breaks through the darkness. The imagery of dark stumps, rising seas, blizzards, light, and flame powerfully convey that juxtaposition.

Han Kang was awarded the Nobel Prize in literature in 2024 for her earlier body of work: The Vegetarian, The White Book, Human Acts, and Greek Lessons. While I’ve not read her earlier works, the combination of imagery, the plotting, and the juxtaposition of a friendship with a horror of history reveals Han Kang’s skill and artistic vision.

Review: Yellowface

/ rtrube54 / Leave a comment
Cover image of "Yellowface" by R. F. Kuang.

Yellowface, R. F. Kuang. William Morrow (ISBN: 9780063250833) 2023.

Summary: What happens when a famous author dies immediately after sharing an unpublished draft of her latest work with her writer friend.

Athena Liu and June Hayward met at Yale. Both were aspiring writers. Athena rocketed to literary stardom. June’s book received lackluster reviews and didn’t sell. Both are living in DC and meet up. They migrate to Athena’s apartment, get drunk, and share a lot of girl talk. Athena shows June the draft of her latest, yet to be submitted book. No one else has seen it. It’s on Chinese laborers in World War I and June sees its potential. Next thing, Athena is choking, June’s efforts to save her fail, and Athena dies before help arrives. When June finally leaves, it is with Athena’s manuscript.

Reading through the manuscript, she recognizes both the brilliance and the unfinished state of what Athena had produced. At first, she edits the work as a writing exercise, for Athena. But the more she works on it, including her own extensive research, the more she considers it hers. She sends it off to her agent, representing it as her work, and not only does he think it brilliant, but so does her publisher, who offers her a huge advance. June publishes under the name Juniper Song (June’s full first name and middle name, but also ethnically ambiguous) with an equally ambiguous author photo.

The book enjoys critical acclaim…and booming sales. Then the controversy hits. At first, she has to defend herself against charge of cultural appropriation as a white girl writing on an Asian subject. Then the first allegations of plagiarism arise, which she manages to fend off, but at a steep internal psychic cost. In this sense, the novel is a kind of “crime and punishment” study of the deepening fear of being exposed coupled with the allure, yet the impossibility of coming clean. In the writing community, plagiarism may be worse than murder. But she also discovers that in stealing Athena’s work, she has become a captive to Athena’s voice, losing her own.

Kuang also exposes the capricious world of publishing, and the vicious world of social media. In particular, Kuang portrays how quickly adulation can turn to death threats and other forms of cancellation. There are even the complicated relationships between authors. June claims Athena stole from her, taking her secrets and turning them into stories. June, of course, uses this to justify her own theft.

This is not a pleasant book to read. Kuang makes us look at our rationalizations, the ways we re-narrate our stories. Simultaneously she explores the dark sides of the publishing, literary, and social media worlds. And she weaves all this together in a compelling story.

Review: The City and Its Uncertain Walls

/ rtrube54 / Leave a comment
Cover image of "The City and Its Uncertain Walls" by Haruki Murakami

The City and Its Uncertain Walls, Haruki Murakami (Translated by Philip Gabriel). Alfred A. Knopf (ISBN: 9780593801970) 2024.

Summary: A young couple falls in love until she disappears to a mysterious city of people without shadows.

A teenage boy meets a girl at a writing competition. They write and are drawn to each other, visiting and cuddling and longing for more. He loses his heart to her but she asks him to be patient, saying she wants to give herself wholly to him. And then she just disappears. But before this happened, she told him that her real self lived in a city with walls, unicorns, a clock tower without hands, and that in that city, she was the librarian. The girl he knew was a mere shadow of that girl.

Understandably, he longs to follow her to that city, but does not know how. He never marries and works in publishing. Then, one day when he is forty-five, he falls into a hole and finds himself outside the city with a wall. To enter, the Gatekeeper must remove his shadow, which will live separately. Then he must go through a painful eye treatment to fit him for his job. He will work with the girl at the library reading everything in its collection. Not books, but the dreams of past inhabitants of the city.

So, each day, he arrives, the girl makes a tea to help his eyes, and gives him egg-shaped dreams to hold and “read.” Then he walks her home along the river to the housing where she lives. But she doesn’t recognize him from their relationship outside the wall. However, his shadow interrupts this companionable routine. The shadow is dying and must return to the outside world. Finally, he is convinced, but turns back at the last minute while the shadow departs.

Yet we meet him next, not in the city but back at home. He has a shadow again. But he is dissatisfied with his life. He asks a friend to help him find a different job in a small town. He applies for a job as a director of a small library. After an interview with the founder and retiring director, Mr. Koyasu, he is hired despite his scant qualifications. Mr. Koyasu is unusual. He wears a distinctive beret and a skirt. But he drops by and mentors the man, including taking him to a secret room that is warmer in winter. Only later do we learn that Mr. Koyasu is dead. A shade if not a shadow!

He finds Koyasu’s grave and talks to him on his days off. And he meets a woman who owns a nearby coffee shop. It appears that, if not first love, then some kind of love might be possible. Except a boy turns up who reads at the library every day, and knowing your birthday, can tell you the day on which you were born. Apart from that, he doesn’t communicate. Yet he connects with the director. And one day he overhears him talking to Mr. Koyasu at the grave about the city…

Shadow and substance. What is real? Murakami gives us his own version of Socrates’ Cave. And do we not sometimes feel alien to our own world, and think there might be another where we are more at home? And yet the nameless narrator doesn’t find his real love in the city without shadows–nor in this one. We wonder if he will accept the possibility of love in front of him from the coffee shop owner. Apart from that relationship, one feels he is living a shadow existence, unconnected with others in the town.

This is the second Murakami novel I’ve read, and I find myself drawn to his narrative voice. It is both quiet and evocative without becoming overpowering. He draws the reader into the mental and emotional landscape of his main character. Then he throws enough surprises and twist in to keep it interesting and make you wonder where this is going.

Murakami adds a fascinating postscript. He first wrote this story as a novella forty years ago but never was satisfied with the ending. This work is a re-working as he finally found a way to complete the story. We learn he added parts two and three. I’ve not read the earlier work. I’d like to hear from Murakami fans who have read both this and the earlier novella. Do you think he succeeded?

Review: Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow

/ rtrube54 / Leave a comment
Cover image of "Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow" by Gabrielle Zevin

Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, Gabrielle Zevin. Vintage Books (ISBN: 9780593466490) 2022.

Summary: Childhood friends, Sam and Sadie collaborate as game developers, in a different kind of love story.

From the ancient Greeks to C. S. Lewis, people have written of the different kinds of love. This is a story of a different kind of love. One that is not familial, nor one simply of friendship, nor erotic. Sadie meets Sam when they are both eleven. Sadie’s sister is being treated for cancer. Sam is recovering from surgery to try to put together his left foot, mangled in a car accident. One that took the life of his mother. She meets him in the hospital game room during one of those interminable times of waiting around when someone you care for is in the hospital. He’s really good at Super Mario Brothers. And they strike up a friendship.

Only later does she learn from a nurse that this is the first time he has spoken since the accident. So the nurse asks if Sadie would continue to visit. Her mother reminds her of the service requirement for her Bat Mitzvah. So surreptitiously, she gets credit for her time visiting Sam–over 600 hours! And they deeply connect, Grok, if you will, until Sam learns that she has counted her time with him for her service project. He cruelly ends the relationship until…

They run into each other seven years later in Harvard Square. She is a student at MIT, and he, at Harvard. Sam spots her and manages to get her attention by calling out a favorite phrase from their gaming discussions. She is delighted to see him and hands him a floppy disk of a game she has written for a class. And so resumes the complicated friendship of Sadie and Sam.

Sam plays the game and loves it. They talk, and conclude that they ought to work on games together. They develop a game, Ichigo, in which a genderless child tries to survive being swept to sea in a giant wave. Sam’s roommate, Marx, offers their apartment as a workspace, and helps support the effort with everything from food to promotional ideas.

Sam and Sadie’s collaboration makes each of them, and the game better. There is a kind of oneness of mind between them that is more than close friends or even lovers, which they never become. Sadie’s lover was a former prof, Dov, a brilliant game developer who also had a penchant for sado-masochism. Sadie eventually gets out of the relationship, but not before securing permission to use Dov’s game engine to create visual effects for the game. Sam had urged this on her, oblivious to what he was asking. And so begin the tensions between them that intensify when they try to sell the game to a company that wants to make Ichigo male. Ideas of success and creative tensions pull at the collaboration, which Marx, now their business manager tries to hold together.

Then game promotion complicates things. Sadie’s insecurity comes out and Sam is the one on the stages promoting the game, and treated as its creator in the male world of gaming. While he gives Sadie due credit, press perceptions still represent Ichigo as his game, even though it was significantly an expression of Sadie’s genius and developing skills. And it is wildly successful. A sequel is developed, and Sam, Sadie, and Marx use their profits to create their own company.

Gabrielle Zevin traces this complicated friendship over 30 years as they build a company and do amazing creative work. Yet Sam drives himself so hard that his cobbled-together foot becomes infected, jeopardizing his life. Sadie and Sam create a “two worlds” game. Sadie’s side is technically brilliant, but it is Sam’s more prosaic side to which people flock. While creating non-violent games, an act of real world violence devastates both of them, and their company, and further drives them apart.

The title, quoted by Marx from Shakespeare, alludes to the allure of games, in which no character ever dies permanently. They keep coming back with each new game play. Both are haunted by death. Each asks if the other is dying when they first meet. Sam witnesses a woman jump from a building, landing in front of him and his mother walking on the sidewalk. Sam’s mother, on the cusp of success in Hollywood, dies when another driver fails to see them parked on the side of a road at night. Then, in the time following the act of violence, we wonder whether the unique love between Sadie and Sam will be stronger than death.

I am not into the gaming world, and my world is a far cry from the one Zevin creates. Yet the compelling characters and their unique, fraught relationship drew me in. Zevin offers an exploration of what an intellectual, creative, and yet deeply bonded love that is non-sexual might look like. She subtly underscores the toxic masculinity of the gaming industry, and the flaws in a society that believes in solving problems with a gun. It does not surprise me that Zevin is the recipient of numerous book awards. I will be on the lookout for her next work.

Review: Tom Lake

/ rtrube54 / Leave a comment
Cover image of "Tom Lake" by Ann Patchett

Tom Lake, Ann Patchett. HarperCollins (ISBN: 9780063327528) 2023.

Summary: Lara, while cherry-picking with her daughters, recounts her love affair with actor Peter Duke, and how she met the girls’ father.

This is one of the best stories I’ve read with the COVID pandemic as a backdrop. In the summer of 2020, Lara’s three daughters have returned home to her and Joe’s orchard near Traverse Bay, in northern Michigan. And its a good thing, because the pandemic has thinned the ranks of workers who usually pick cherries. So it is “all hands” and Lara and her daughters spend their days in the orchards.

Nell, the youngest, is an aspiring actress. She knew her mother not only had a brief acting career but had a summer-long love affair with Peter Duke, who later went on to become a screen actor. None of them knew much about this part of their mother’s life. So, plying her with questions, Lara, over successive days of pickings, and evenings at the kitchen table, unfolds the story–at least most of it.

Beginning with high school, she recounts getting the part of Emily (the name of her oldest daughter) in Thornton Wilder’s Our Town. She stars in the same role in college, and in a turn of fate, a Hollywood agent realizes she is perfect for a film in the works. She turns in what everyone says is a great performance, but the film sits in the can. Her agent gets her an audition for a Broadway production. She’s good enough, but without the movie, not famous enough. Just then a popular summer stock company loses their “Emily” and she takes the part.

The company is located by Tom Lake, in northern Michigan, part of a cultural festival site with offerings for downstate residents and others fleeing the heat. Another cast member, Peter Duke is a young, good-looking, and charismatic figure, and before long, Lara and Peter are lovers. Lara tells (and remembers) the story of that relationship, in the life cycle of a summer stock production where days are weeks, weeks are months and months, years.

Casts develop tight relationships. Thus we not only meet Peter Duke, but also Pallace, a Black woman who is Lara’s understudy, fighting the prejudice that wouldn’t cast “Emily” as Black. Pallace falls in love with Sebastian, Peter’s brother, a tennis pro at an exclusive Detroit area club. And we meet Uncle Wallace, a venerable old actor who plays the stage manager. Sadly, Uncle Wallace collapses in Lara’s arms during a performance, a consequence of years of drinking.

Toward the end of the season, Peter and Lara are rehearsing another role. To get into the role, which Lara plays badly, they drink (as do their characters. Lara then plays a tennis match with Sebastian, the best in her life, until she blows out her Achilles tendon. She cannot take the Stage as Emily. And she realizes that playing Emily is about the extent of her talent. And Duke moves on to Pallace. At the end of the summer, they part ways, and Peter begins his ascent to Hollywood fame, ironically through Lara’s agent

She also tells the story of meeting her husband, who was also at Tom Lake that summer. Because of Peter Duke, he couldn’t tell her. Only later do they connect, marry, and make the cherry farm their home. Patchett offers an interesting contrast between the meteoric passion between Peter and Lara, and the quieter, durable love of Joe.

Patchett explores the intricacies of the stories of our youth. Lara must decide what to tell her daughters as she remembers. We learn of one memory that remains secret, except to the readers.

Patchett also weaves in an underlying story of place. The cherry farm had belonged to Joe’s Uncle Ken and Aunt Maisie (after whom the middle daughter is named). And Emily, the eldest, and her fiance, Nelson, are already thinking of the future of the orchard, perhaps combined with the farm of Nelson’s neighboring parents. Meanwhile, Maisie, a veterinarian in training, already is caring for the community’s animals. Only Nell has aspirations to move away and act. I wonder if she will after this story!

I won’t say how Patchett ends this one. I’ve not always found her endings satisfying, as much as I’m a fan of her writing. While there are some unexpected twists in this one, I felt the conclusion just “fit” for me as did the conclusion to The Dutch House.

Review: The Man Within

/ rtrube54 / Leave a comment
Cover image for "The Man Within" by Graham Greene

The Man Within, Graham Greene. Open Road Media (ISBN: 9781504054003), 2018 (First published in 1929).

Summary: Francis Andrews flight from smugglers he betrayed endangers a girl with whom he takes refuge.

This is Graham Greene’s first published novel. The main character is Francis Andrews, son of an abusive smuggler. When his father died, Carlyon, his second, took him under his wing in the smuggling business. But he never fits in, no more than he did with his father. Consequently, he writes a letter to customs officers, tipping them off to the smugglers’ whereabouts.. When the customs officers show up, Andrews escapes during the fight that ensues, leaving a customs officer dead.

A group of the men are taken into custody and face murder charges. But Carlyon escapes and is hunting Andrews, his former friend. During a foggy night, Andrews flees across the downs, knowing that if Carlyon finds him, Carlyon will kill him. Desperate, he seeks shelter in a cottage whose only inhabitant is a young woman, Elizabeth. Actually, when he arrives, he finds himself face to face with a corpse, a man who had been Elizabeth’s guardian after her own father died.

Elizabeth shelters him, passing him off as her brother to a nosy cleaning woman. When Andrews tries to leave, he nearly encounters Carlyon on the road and retreats to the cottage. Elizabeth hides him and Carlyon leaves. A bond forms between them. She doesn’t want to be alone. But she also senses the turmoil Andrews struggles with in what seems a cowardly betrayal. She urges him to go to the assizes where the men will be tried, to give his testimony. He does, although he makes a hash of it. Not only is his testimony compromised by the cleaning woman, who identifies him as staying with Elizabeth, who she calls “a loose woman.” He sleeps with another woman, who was a kind of bribe for his testimony. The smugglers are acquitted and Andrews is the object of opprobrium.

Elizabeth is also in jeopardy. Carlyon is on the loose as are the other men. They know she hid Andrews. And this exposes the central thread of the whole story. Andrews struggles with seeing himself as a coward, a legacy of his father’s abuse. He saw betraying the smugglers as a way to strike back, yet betrayal feels the ultimate cowardly act. Now, will he save his own skin, confirming what “the man within” has been saying? Or will he attempt to save Elizabeth? She acted in courage in her love for him. Will he? And what risks and consequences could this mean for them both.

In a sense, Greene offers us two people dealing with a person within, the voices of the dead they are seeking to live free of. Each is bereft when they meet the other, alone in the world. Each faces the question of “is love worth the risk?” In this first published work, Greene gives us characters we come to care for and explores large questions such as the line between cowardice and courage and the risks of love.

Review: The Song of the Lark

/ rtrube54 / Leave a comment
Cover image of "The Song of the Lark" by Willa Cather

The Song of the Lark (Prairie Trilogy), Willa Cather. Open Road Media (ISBN: 9781504035361), 2016 (First published in 1915). 

Summary: A young woman from a frontier town discovers her passion for music, eventually taking her to the world’s opera stages.

Thea Kornberg nearly did not survive her childhood in the frontier town of Moonstone, Colorado. Deathly ill with pneumonia, only the ministrations of Dr. Howard Archie, then just a country doctor, save her life. The experience also forges a lasting bond between them. As the daughter of a minister, learning piano and singing were par for the course. Yet even as a child, Wunsch, her piano teacher discovers an unusual passion for excellence. Not only does she exhaust his ability to train her. She also recruits her own students and replaces Wunsch after a moral lapse forces his departure from Moonstone.

She also attracts the attentions of Ray Kennedy, a railroader who wants to marry her when she comes of age. But his longing is never fulfilled. He dies in a rail accident. But, knowing her unfulfilled potential as a musician, he leaves her a bequest of $600 to send her to Chicago. She is fortunate to train with Andor Harsanyi. But he describes himself as exhausted after piano lessons with her because of her intensity. Yet he wonders if the piano is her instrument. When he learns that she sings in a church choir, he asks to hear her sing. He realizes that her voice is her instrument.

He connects her with Madison Bowers, the best voice teacher in Chicago. Although not a pleasant man, she develops as a singer under his instruction. To pay her way, she also accompanies other students but quickly comes to despise their stupidity. On the edge of disillusionment, she is introduced to Fred Ottenberg and a Jewish family who are friends of his, the Nathanmeyers. The chance to sing at their music parties kindles her love of performing. But she is worn out and ill. Fred whisks her off to a friend with a ranch near ancient cliff dwellings.

She comes to understand her passion to perform, how it is a part of every fiber of her being, during months of solitude. Meanwhile, she is falling in love with Fred. But she learns that he is married and bound to a mentally invalid wife. From New York, she wires Dr. Archie, who has always looked out for her, having escorted her to Chicago. She will accept no further help from Fred, despite the fact that he is from a wealthy brewing family. Yet they remain on friendly terms. Dr, Archie provides her a loan to go to Europe to continue to train.

The work concludes in New York. Dr, Archie, Fred, Harsanyi, and even Spanish Johnny, from the Mexican part of Moonstone, hear her perform at the Met to acclaim. Through their eyes, we glimpse the full realization of the passions and drives that have animated her life, poured out in performance. And we see the contempt she feels toward mediocrity. We observe the life of a diva, and what she left behind–the prairies, her parents, who died while she was in Europe, and those who stood in her way. And those who attend her performance remind us of those without whom it would not have been possible.

As in the other Prairie trilogy novels, Cather draws a compellingly strong female character. Having been around singers, I also thought she really got inside the psyche of a singer, exploring what makes them great. It’s not merely a voice but how the voice and the music become the means through which a whole personality expresses itself. We also see the sheer work involved, not only the practice but getting inside the idea of a piece and giving expression to that with one’s whole body.

Review: Long Island

/ rtrube54 / 1 Comment
Cover image of "Long Island" by Colm Tóibín

Long Island (Eilis Lacey No. 2), Colm Tóibín. Scribner (ISBN: 9781476785110) 2024

Summary: Eilis Lacey returns to her home in Ireland when she learns the wife of a customer of her husband is carrying his child.

Eilis Lacey Fiorello answers the door and there is the Irishman who has called several times. In short order, she learns that the man’s wife, who had hired Tony to do plumbing work, is pregnant with Tony’s child. Not only that, he tells her that he will not allow the child in his house but will leave it at the Fiorello’s house. It is their problem. In this sequel to Brooklyn, this bombshell drops in the opening pages and everything else unfolds from there.

Eilis confronts Tony and learns it is all true. Then she makes clear her own decision about the matter. She will not raise the child. She will not deal with this. Nor will she accept Tony’s mother Francesca raising the child. Tony, two of his brothers, and his parents live in an enclave on Long Island. She would still see the child everyday. And as she interacts with Francesca, she is reminded of how much she has always felt the outsider in this close-knit Italian family.

As it happens, Eilis mother’s eightieth birthday is that summer. As a way of underscoring that she will have nothing to do with the child, she plans a visit home to Enniscorthy to coincide with the baby’s birth. She leaves a month early, but arranges for Larry and Rosella, the teenage grandchildren her mother has never seen except in pictures, to arrive in time for the birthday.

But there is more to it than getting away from a painful situation and reconnecting with an aging mother (who knows more than she lets on). There is Jim Farrell. Jim owns a bar in Enniscorthy, above which he lives. After Eilis met and married Tony, she returned for a visit, before her children were born. While there, she met Jim and they had an affair. But her marriage was kept secret, and she suddenly left. And Jim never married, heartbroken with her departure.

Now Jim has been seeing Nancy, who owns a nearby chip shop, and she’s stayed overnight. Recently, they have agreed to get engaged. With the encouragement of their priest, they are planning a Rome wedding the following spring. But they’ve kept the engagement secret, ostensibly to not upstage the wedding of Nancy’s daughter by her first husband, now deceased. While Eilis still lived in Enniscorthy, she and Nancy were best friends.

As you can guess, the old flames re-connect and flame up once more. Eilis doesn’t know about Nancy and Jim doesn’t reveal the secret engagement. Secrets run through this story. Eilis’s secret affair with Jim after she and Tony had married. Tony’s secret liaisons. Nancy and Jim’s secret engagement. A rekindled secret affair. Secrets, as often the case, are not a good thing.

There is also the tension of keeping faith with oneself and with others, especially when commitments conflict and become acts of betrayal. Tony, Eilis, and Jim are all caught up in that tension. Can such entanglements end well? I will leave it to the reader to decide, and to assess how Tóibín has developed his characters and the choices they make.

Review: Waiting for Al Gore

/ rtrube54 / Leave a comment
Cover image of "Waiting for Al Gore" by Bob Katz.

Waiting for Al Gore, Bob Katz. Flexible Press (ISBN: 9798988721321) 2024.

Summary: A story that pairs a struggling writer and a struggling environmental group hoping a conference becomes a big story when Gore shows up.

Lenny Beibel is driving his old Toyota Corolla to a rendezvous to pick up two leaders of a fringe environmental group. Rachel Seagrave is the founder of EarthKare and Frederick Wolfram is her earnest but overbearing communications director and assistant. They are meeting the rest of the rag-tag team at a rural Vermont camp owned by EarthKare, which will be the site of what they hope will be a game-changing environmental story. That is, if Al Gore shows up.

Everyone is swinging for the fences here. Lenny is a struggling freelance writer and EarthKare is struggling to hold onto followers. To be sure, they invited Gore months earlier. But his agent keeps stringing them along. Then she offers them a pinch hitter, Henry Marks, a jogger turned motivational speaker with a gig he calls JogThink. His audiences tend to be company retreats and cruise ship passengers. Somehow, the offer becomes a gift–Henry is coming pro bono. Rachel is assured the crowd will love him.

Then another unusual guest makes a fleeting appearance. Oswald’s thrush was thought to be extinct. Then there are several sightings, none long enough to be confirmed, but word gets out to a group of birders. The bird is elusive, the kind you only get to see out of the corner of your eye.

Meanwhile, Henry show up in the midst of preparations for a group of unknown size. And he seems the flake to complement what seems a disaster in the making. His first act is to take the whole group on a jog, not too fast. Slow jogging together spurs creative thinking. Wolfram foresees disaster and sees it as the opportunity to come to the rescue if Henry’s keynote flops. While Wolfram prepares for the worst, both Lenny and Henry do their best to court Rachel. And Rachel is courtable, although neither appear great prospects. The clock is ticking and she is weary of leading EarthKare, despite their urgent mission.

We read on wondering what will become of this trainwreck in the making, especially when a respectable crowd shows up. Bob Katz, a writer I’ve reviewed before, constructs a tale of idealists and bumblers hoping magic will happen in service of their urgent cause. And without preaching, he gets across the point that our situation is such that its not a time to jog but to run like hell but not without hope. You never know when either Oswald’s thrush or Al Gore will turn up.

____________________

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for review.