In the fall, one of Chaney’s early season rivals was Austintown Fitch. Many of us living on Youngstown’s Westside had friends in Austintown and the rivalry was always a big deal. I’ll save the rivalry for another time. Today I write about how Fitch got its name.
John H. Fitch was born on his family’s farm near the center of Austintown in 1843. Eventually he had a farm encompassing over 400 acres with livestock, horses and chickens, near He started working in a grocery store at age 15 and by 22 was part owner with Levi Crum of a successful general store. By 1885, they expanded the store into Youngstown.
In 1901, the John H. Fitch Company was incorporated and in 1902, they bought out a firm selling coffee and tea, resulting in a very successful business, the John H. Fitch Coffee Company, selling nationwide out of a warehouse on Watt Street.
Children in Austintown were educated at small, one-room school houses scattered around the township. Those who went to high school went to nearby schools like Mineral Ridge. By 1915, there were at least eight such one-room schoolhouses around the township. In 1915 John Fitch donated eight acres of his farmland along Mahoning Avenue for the building of a new school to serve the township. In 1916 the Austintown Centralized School opened on that site in the building many of us went past (or even went to school in) in our younger years. In 1922, the school added grades 10-12. The building later served as the district high school until the move to its new building in 1968.
John H. Fitch also donated the land for the YMCA that bears his name, Camp Fitch. The original camp was on Little Beaver Creek south of Lisbon. After his death, the family donated the money to purchase the 93 acre site where Camp Fitch is currently located on Lake Erie.
John H. Fitch died in 1919. Frank Ohl, Fitch’s farm manager and active in school and township affairs led a petition drive to name the school after Fitch and in 1924, the school was renamed Austintown Fitch School, the name remaining as the name of the high school after elementary and middle schools were built.
And that is where the name “Fitch” came from, and the school that became Chaney’s football rival.
To read other posts in the Growing Up in Working Class Youngstown series, just click “On Youngstown.” Enjoy!


