Growing Up in Working Class Youngstown — Liberty Township

By P. J. Browne, surveyor [2] – Map of Trumbull County, Ohio (Philadelphia: Gillette Matthews & Co., 1856) [1] hosted at Newton Falls Information Network, Public Domain,

I don’t think I realized until I was older that Liberty Township wasn’t part of Youngstown. As a kid, we used to go to church picnics at Churchill Park. In high school, a girl I dated for a bit lived in Liberty. I remember walking from her home to the Liberty Plaza to watch Let it Be. That was probably bad luck. We broke up shortly after watching the movie about the break up of the Beatles. In later years my wife and I got meals at the Bob Evans and at Kravitz’s Deli (one of my dad’s favorites), and at Station Square with friends. All those places are in Liberty Township.

Liberty Township isn’t a part of Youngstown. It isn’t even part of Mahoning County, but rather Trumbull County. But I’m not the only one to connect them. Local historian Howard C. Aley writes,

No other community on Mahoning County’s perimeter has quite the same unique relationship that exists between Liberty Township and its neighboring political subdivision to the south. Contrary to Robert Frost’s neighbor who contended that “Good fences make good neighbors,” there are no fences between Liberty Township and the Youngstown boundary lines, and the communities are, indeed, good neighbors.

Aley wrote this in 1976. Much has changed and I wonder whether the two communities would still think this way, but it does illustrate the close connection. At one time, some of the elite Youngstown families had estates in Liberty Township–the McKelveys, the Logans, the Andrew, the Wicks, and the Stambaughs.

Liberty Township Map from 1918

Did you know that Liberty Township is one of 25 Liberty Townships in Ohio? We live just south of one near Columbus, also in a neighboring county. It was one of the five by five mile townships laid out in the survey of the Western Reserve, west of Hubbard and east of Weathersfield Township. And if you remember, Youngstown, just to the south was at one time part of Trumbull County until Mahoning County was created in 1846. Liberty Township was established in 1806, though settled as early as 1798.

Present day Liberty Township consists of the Village of Girard and unincorporated township lands. At one time there were also villages of Churchill, Sodom, and Seceders Corners. Churchill is a Census Designated Place to this day. The others have disappeared.

Peter Kline

Much of the land outside of Girard was farmland. In 1860 coal was discovered on Alexander McCleery’s farm. Peter Kline, son of one of the leading families in the area amassed the largest farm in Liberty Township, bordering on Churchill, with 700 acres, much of which was devoted to livestock. He also had the good fortune of having coal discovered on his land, mined by Tod, Stambaugh, & Co. At one time 17 mines were operating in the township. Samuel Goist’s farm was a stopping point on the Underground Railroad.

The township is led by elected township trustees and a financial officer. Outside of Girard, the education is provided by the Liberty Township School District including E. J. Blott Elementary School, William S. Guy Middle School, and Liberty High School. Former director of the Ohio Department of Health Amy Acton, who led the state’s early response to COVID-19, is a Liberty High School graduate.

Liberty Plaza, probably in the 1960’s. Photo by Hank Perkins, used with permission of the Mahoning Valley History Society Business and Media Archives collection (http://mahoninghistory.org).

The complexion of the southern part of Liberty Township along Belmont Avenue has changed. Liberty Plaza was one of the premiere shopping centers in the area at one time. Now the area is a Walmart and a small strip of stores. At the same time, a complex of restaurants and lodgings have sprung up around the I-80 interchange with Belmont. Further south, Jack Kravitz continues to serve up some of the best deli food in the area. And to the north, the township retains its rural character.

Liberty Township. Youngstown’s near neighbor. Stop off place for interstate travelers. Gateway to rural northeast Ohio.

10 thoughts on “Growing Up in Working Class Youngstown — Liberty Township

  1. I am pretty certain that Kravitz Deli was on Belmont Avenue in Youngstown. I worked around the corner from 1970 to 1977 and enjoyed lunch there frequently.

  2. The mention of Howard Aley caused me to have flash backs to my high school days at Wilson. Mr. Aley was a teacher there for many years. He was also the advisor for our school newspaper where I had the most contact with him.

    Like you, I never realized that Liberty was not part of Youngstown until much later. I can’t pinpoint the exact time but I am sure that I was a student at YSU.

  3. Liberty Township of my hometown and I lived there from 1952 (I was one year old.) until December 1979, when my parents sold our home and I graduated from YSU in June 1980 (BE in Civil Engineering). I graduated from Liberth H.S. in 1969.
    Legally, the City of Girard has not been a part of Liberty Township since the early or mid-1970s when the voters of Liberty Township voted not once but twice to disolve the original Liberty Township dating back to the Connecticut Western Reserve and establish a new Liberty Township that did not include the City of Girard and the City of Youngstown (Northside Hospital and Stambaugh Golf Course).
    The state legislation which allowed the old township to be disolved and a new one created was legislation that the late Clingan Jackson (https://bobonbooks.com/2019/05/04/growing-up-in-working-class-youngstown-clingan-jackson/ and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clingan_Jackson), long time Political Editor of The Vindicator, had sponsored when he sat in the State House of Representives in the late 1940s (My memory is slipping and it could have been when he was a Representive in the 1930s). The first time the voters of the Township voted to creat the new township the City of Girard went to court to invalidate the vote on a legal technicality which resulted in the law to be amended and the voters of the Township voted again and once again the desire for a new Liberty Township prevailed and all further court challenges failed.
    Jackson’s family was one of the first Youngstown and settled in Coitsville Township. He wrote and sponsored the legislation that was used by Liberty Township as a way for Coitsville Township to fight off annexation from the City of Youngstown. I had Jackson for State and Local Government at YSU after the second vote to disolve and create a new Township and I had quite a few wonderful conversations about the situation in the Township. He was still Political Editor of The Vindicator at the time and had watched the situation closely.

      • One other interesting reason for dissolving the old Township was that people who lived in the Girard area of Liberty Township did not pay township taxes and could not vote on township issues but run for and be elected as a township Trustee. The late Bob Hagen (I don’t when he passed away but he was older than my father who was born in 1920.) was a Republican politician who lived in Girard was a Township Trustee in the late 1960s and early 1970s and the fact that he, a resident of Girard, was a Trustee was a driving force in the movement to dissolve the old township.

  4. Dear Bob Trube,
    We are FB friends and I follow you on bobonbooks also! This article is near and dear to my heart! My Dad (from 1920-31) & Aunt (from 1913-24) went to Churchill School and Liberty School and my Grandmother taught there about 1900. I’ve made two trips to the area, and in August I made a (somewhat lonely!) trip and drove around Liberty, Vienna and Brookfield.
    I have 100 year old photos of the schools, also of Liberty Twp., Coalburg and vicinity. I wish I knew what to do with them.
    Anyway, thanks for this!!
    Lynn Dingledy Topar

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.